Making a truly exceptional apple pie is no simple feat; it’s a delicate balance of textures and flavors that can easily go awry. It’s a dessert that promises comforting warmth and familiar sweetness, yet achieving perfection can feel like chasing a culinary unicorn. For years, the ideal apple pie—one with tender apples, a rich, thick filling, and a perfectly flaky bottom crust—remained elusive in my kitchen. Store-bought versions consistently fell short, often delivering crunchy apples swimming in a watery filling encased in a soggy crust. The quest for the perfect homemade apple pie felt like navigating a geometric theorem without a protractor, complex and frustrating.
Driven by a mix of ambition and perhaps a touch of overconfidence, I embarked on my apple pie journey. Like many novice bakers, I turned to a trusted name in home cooking: the Pioneer Woman. Ree Drummond, with her warm, approachable style, seemed like the perfect guide to conquering this classic dessert. I chose her Caramel Apple Pie recipe, drawn in by the promise of gooey caramel and the comforting familiarity of her brand. Ah, youthful optimism! I was convinced that with Pioneer Woman’s guidance, I could bypass the common pitfalls and create apple pie perfection.
Geometric bliss. It
The Pioneer Woman’s recipe took a straightforward approach: combine raw Granny Smith apples with lemon juice, flour, sugar, and salt for the filling. This mixture was then topped with a crumbly mixture of flour, butter, brown sugar, and raw quick-cooking oats – an unusual element that left me slightly puzzled. The recipe’s grand finale was the instruction to generously drench the baked pie with up to two cups of caramel sauce. Eager and perhaps a little naive, I even went the extra mile to make homemade caramel sauce, envisioning a decadent, caramel-infused apple pie masterpiece.
However, the reality was far from the dream. Despite my best efforts, the Pioneer Woman Caramel Apple Pie was, to put it kindly, a culinary catastrophe. The promised caramel deluge did indeed cascade over the pie, creating a sticky perimeter that extended far beyond the pie dish itself. But the visual mess was the least of my worries. The apples remained stubbornly crunchy, almost raw, as if they had merely been warmed, not baked. The filling, far from being thick and luscious, was thin and watery, escaping the moment a slice was cut. And the crumb topping? The raw oats remained stubbornly raw, adding an unpleasant, gritty texture to the already disappointing pie. It was a bizarre textural paradox – soggy and hard all at once. The caramel, while delicious on its own, couldn’t salvage the fundamentally flawed pie.
I adore this ceramic knife. It cuts through apple pie like it
Undeterred, or perhaps foolishly persistent, I attempted a second iteration of apple pie, this time abandoning the crumb topping in favor of a traditional pie crust. I also wisely omitted the caramel sauce, still faintly traumatized by the sticky aftermath of the first attempt. Yet, even with these adjustments, the pie remained stubbornly inedible. It was disheartening to realize that even simplifying the recipe couldn’t overcome the fundamental issues. Defeated and vowing never to attempt apple pie again, I resigned myself to a pie-less existence, convinced that a truly good apple pie was an unattainable myth, at least in my kitchen. My Pioneer Woman caramel apple pie experience had left me deeply disillusioned.
Six long years passed in apple pie abstinence. But the siren call of a perfect apple pie eventually proved too strong to resist. This time, I decided to approach the challenge with a more scientific and less whimsical approach. I turned to Cook’s Illustrated, renowned for their rigorous recipe testing and commitment to understanding the science of cooking. Their methodical approach offered a beacon of hope after my Pioneer Woman-inspired failure.
From Cook’s Illustrated, I learned a crucial piece of apple pie wisdom: pectin, the natural substance in apples that helps them set, behaves in a peculiar way under heat. At high baking temperatures, pectin breaks down, contributing to runny fillings. However, if apples are gently pre-cooked at a lower temperature, between 140°F and 160°F, for a short period, the pectin transforms into a heat-stable form. This pre-cooking step is the key to achieving tender, yet structurally intact apples in a baked pie. This revelation was a game-changer. It explained why my previous attempts, and countless others, resulted in crunchy apples and watery fillings. The Pioneer Woman recipe, by using raw apples, skipped this crucial step, leading to the textural issues I encountered.
A close-up of the flaky crust this recipe produces. It
Inspired by Cook’s Illustrated’s principles, I began to formulate my own apple pie recipe. I also explored the idea of directly adding pectin to the filling to further ensure a thick, non-runny consistency. Researching various apple pie recipes, I discovered that some bakers indeed incorporated pectin and cornstarch for enhanced thickening. I decided to adopt this strategy, adding both pectin and cornstarch to my filling. This combination proved incredibly effective, resulting in a beautifully thick and sliceable pie filling, a stark contrast to the watery mess of my Pioneer Woman attempt.
While focusing on texture, I also considered flavor. Beyond cinnamon, I contemplated adding nutmeg, ginger, and allspice for a more complex spice profile. However, mindful of overwhelming the apple flavor, I opted for a conservative approach, sticking initially with just cinnamon. I reasoned that a subtle hint of other spices could enhance, rather than mask, the apple’s natural taste. Later experiments confirmed that a small amount of nutmeg, ginger, and allspice could indeed add a delightful layer of complexity without overpowering the apple.
The Cook’s Illustrated recipe I consulted used a generous five pounds of apples, enough for two pies. I decided to halve the apple filling and experiment with the second batch. To this experimental half, I added extra pectin, cinnamon, and a touch of vanilla extract. This second batch was transformed into a Dutch apple pie, and while I found the vanilla a bit overpowering (I had mistakenly doubled the intended amount), my husband loved it. This highlighted the subjective nature of flavor preferences, and the potential for vanilla to complement apple pie, especially in smaller quantities.
Addressing the persistent soggy bottom crust issue, a common apple pie nemesis, I employed several techniques. I used a thick, buttery pie crust, the same recipe I relied on for my pecan pie success. Crucially, I blind-baked the bottom crust – pre-baking it before adding the filling. Some bakers also recommend brushing the bottom crust with butter to create a moisture barrier. I believe the combination of a thick, buttery crust, blind baking, and the potential butter barrier all contributed to a bottom crust that was perfectly flaky and crisp, a world away from the soggy disappointment I had previously experienced.
After years of trial, error, and a detour through the caramel-laden landscape of the Pioneer Woman, I had finally achieved apple pie enlightenment. The result was a pie that lived up to the ethereal delight I had always envisioned. The apples were tender, the filling was thick and flavorful, and the crust was flaky perfection. Apple pie, indeed, had become bliss.
Looks like someone
Classic Apple Pie Recipe (Inspired by Cook’s Illustrated)
Yield: One 9-inch apple pie
Ingredients:
For the Crust: (Double this recipe – once for the bottom, once for the top)
- 2 1/2 cups (300 g) all-purpose flour, plus extra for dusting
- 2 TBS (25 g) sugar
- 1 tsp salt
- 12 TBS (1 1/2 sticks) unsalted butter, cold and cut into 1/4-inch pieces
- 8 TBS (1 stick) lard (or vegetable shortening), cold and cut into 6-8 pieces
- 1/4 cup chilled vodka
- 1/4 cup ice water
- 2 TBS heavy cream, for brushing
- 1/4 cup sugar, for sprinkling
For the Filling:
- 1 cup granulated sugar
- 1/3 cup light brown sugar, packed
- 1 tsp ground cinnamon
- 1 generous TBS cornstarch
- 3 tsp powdered pectin (SurJell or Pomona’s Universal Pectin)
- 4 TBS unsalted butter, cut into 1/4-inch pieces
- 1 1/4 lbs Granny Smith apples, peeled, cored, and sliced 1/8-inch thick
- 1 1/4 lbs Golden Delicious apples, peeled, cored, and sliced 1/8-inch thick
- Boiling water (1.875 quarts for 2.5 lbs apples)
Method:
Crust:
- Chill butter and lard in freezer for 15 minutes. Freeze vodka and ice water separately, then combine and chill further.
- Process 1 1/2 cups flour, sugar, and salt in food processor until combined (5-8 seconds).
- Scatter butter and lard over flour mixture; process until paste-like (about 15 seconds).
- Scrape bowl, redistribute dough. Add remaining 1 cup flour; process until small, dry clumps form (4-8 seconds). Avoid over-processing.
- Transfer to bowl. Pour vodka and ice water over dough. Press and flip dough with spatula until liquid absorbed and sticky ball forms.
- Wrap dough in plastic wrap; refrigerate until firm (at least 1 hour).
- Repeat for second crust.
Filling:
- Mix sugars, cinnamon, cornstarch, and pectin in bowl. Add butter; toss.
- Place sliced apples in large heatproof bowl. Pour boiling water over apples; let stand 10 minutes, stirring occasionally.
- Drain apples. Return to bowl. Add sugar mixture; toss to combine. Cool completely.
Assembly & Baking:
- Preheat oven to 425°F (or 350°F if your oven runs hot).
- Roll out chilled dough on floured surface to 1/2-inch thickness. Refrigerate rolled dough for 10-15 minutes.
- Transfer dough to pie plate. Press into plate, avoid stretching. Crimp edges, overhang 1 inch. Poke bottom with fork. Refrigerate 30-60 minutes.
- Cover crust with foil, add pie weights (or dried beans). Blind-bake for 45 minutes (or 25-35 mins at 425°F).
- Remove weights and foil; bake 4-7 minutes more, until lightly golden. Cool completely.
- Roll out second dough for top crust; refrigerate.
- Reduce oven to 350°F (or 325°F).
- Pour cooled apple filling into pre-baked crust. Top with second crust. Crimp edges. Brush with cream, sprinkle with sugar. Cut vents in top crust.
- Bake for 30 minutes. Tent with foil; bake 1 hour more. Remove foil; bake 30 minutes more, until golden.
- Cool completely on rack before slicing.
Notes:
Filling Yields Extra: This recipe makes enough filling for two pies. Halve filling ingredients for one pie or save half for another use (cake filling, etc.)
Sugar Adjustment: Adjust sugar levels to your preference. Up to 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar and 1/2 cup brown sugar can be used for a sweeter pie.
Spice Variations: Nutmeg, ginger, allspice (max 1/4 tsp each) can be added for a more complex spice flavor.
Sources:
- Crust: Cook’s Illustrated All-Time Best Holiday Baking, 2013
- Filling: Cook’s Illustrated All-Time Best Holiday Baking, 2013, Leite’s Culinaria, Serious Eats
- Tips: Serious Eats
I couldn
